Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts

Monday, May 11, 2009

MPs miss chance to embrace YouTube generation

Youtube In the spring of 2007, Friends of Canadian Broadcasting, the well-known broadcasting advocacy group, began posting videos and podcasts of Parliamentary committee proceedings on the group's website. When officials at the House of Commons caught wind of the activities, they promptly sent a "cease and desist" letter, demanding that the videos and podcasts be removed from the Internet. A lawyer for the House of Commons argued that posting excerpts from committee proceedings could be treated as "contempt of Parliament."

The group responded that members did not want to remove the videos but would be willing to follow a reasonable procedure to obtain the necessary permissions.

That response did not sit well with the chairs of the Finance and Canadian Heritage Standing Committees, who upon learning that the group was offering webcasts and downloads of their proceedings, asked the Standing Committee on Procedure and House Affairs (SCPHA) to examine the issue to prevent further infringement.

The notion that videos of committee hearings constitute proprietary content that when used without permission raise the potential for allegations of contempt of Parliament will undoubtedly come as news to many Canadians. Using these excerpts in YouTube videos, webcasts, or podcasts has emerged as an important and powerful tool for business and consumer groups to educate the public on policy issues and legislative proposals.

Yet, House of Commons lawyers maintain that many of these activities violate the law and have sent notice and takedown demands to YouTube seeking the removal of videos that include House of Commons and committee proceedings. These include clips that involve satire and parody, since they are seen to "distort" the video itself.

SCPHA hearings held earlier this year revealed that Canada's elected officials safeguard Parliamentary video with highly restrictive licencing requirements that are typically limited to use in schools or for private study, research, criticism or review. Relying on Crown copyright, the policy states that any other use – including any commercial use – requires the express prior written approval of the Speaker of the House of Commons.

This stands in sharp contrast to the circumstance in the United States, where the default presumption is that such videos are in the public domain and can be freely used without permission. House of Commons lawyers portrayed that approach as representing an extreme position.

To their credit, most of the MPs on the committee recognized that changes to the policies in the YouTube era are needed. However, MPs from the three opposition parties expressed reluctance to mirror the U.S. approach, fearing that some videos taken out of context could be "terrifically damaging." Bloc MP Claude DeBellefeuille raised the possibility of lawsuits to enforce the copyright and noted that "we will have to establish rules so that we have some recourse and that remarks can be withdrawn after they have been broadcast and pointed out."

Conservative MP Scott Reid came closest to recognizing the problems associated with retaining certain restrictions, warning against policies that provide that videos are "usable for certain purposes but not for the purposes that lie at the heart of what this speech is for." Instead, he argued that using video excerpts for either favourable or critical purposes would be appropriate.

The committee adopted a liberalized policy that permits non-commercial reproduction without prior permission. Commercial uses still require prior approval, while distorting a video for parody, satire or political comment may still lead to demands for its removal. The new policy is a modest improvement, but it fails to fully realize the potential of public political participation through online video.


Social Bookmarking

Wednesday, April 22, 2009

Candidate's racy Facebook photos showed 'lack of judgment': B.C. NDP leader

B.C. NDP Leader Carole James says the party's former candidate for Vancouver-False Creek showed a "lack of judgment" over pictures displayed on his Facebook page.

B.C. NDP candidate Ray Lam resigned after 'inappropriate' photos on his private Facebook page became public. Ray Lam resigned on Sunday over the photographs, one of which showed him palming a woman's breast and another with his pants down and two people pulling at his underwear.

"Ray felt that they were inappropriate. Certainly it shows a lack of judgment, and he made the decision to step down," James said on Monday. "He didn't want it to distract from the campaign, so we are moving on."

James said candidates had been warned something like this could happen, saying even though the pictures were posted on a private page, "once you become a public figure, everything is public."

"I saw the pictures on TV. I thought they showed a lack of judgment. It's his age, you know, we all recognize that, but when you're in politics and you are going to be a public figure, it's important that you recognize that," she said.

NDP responsible, Campbell says

B.C. Liberal Leader Gordon Campbell said the B.C. NDP has to take responsibility for the appearance of the images online.

"This was public information. It was on the NDP website and they have some responsibilities in terms of that. - They were totally inappropriate pictures and the NDP has some questions to answer for," he said Monday while campaigning near Vancouver.

Lam should have realized pictures from his private life, if posted online as part of his Facebook profile, would become part of the public record, Campbell said, adding Liberal candidates undergo a strict vetting process that includes online checks.

Campbell himself is no stranger to the troubles the private lives of politicians can cause their public careers.

In 2003 he fended off demands from the B.C. NDP to resign after he was arrested while on vacation in Hawaii and pleaded guilty to several charges related to driving while impaired.

The NDP has until Friday at noon to nominate a replacement and get the necessary papers to Elections BC in order to have a candidate included on the ballot for the May 12 provincial election.

Social Bookmarking

Friday, March 13, 2009

My face, but not my body in film publicity material, Liberal MP Dhalla say

http://doubledoublethoughts.blogspot.com - Former actress, and Current Liberal MP Ruby Dhalla Former actress and Brampton, Ont., Liberal MP Ruby Dhalla is trying to block DVD sales of a Bollywood-style movie she co-starred in before being elected to Parliament in 2004.

In an interview with the Toronto Sun Wednesday, MP Dhalla confirmed her role in the 2003 low-budget Hindi film made in Hamilton called Kyon Kis Liye (Translation: Why? And for Whom?).


However, she claimed the movie's publicity material, including posters and photos, were doctored putting her face on someone else's body.

"We've never seen a copy of the film," said Dhalla, 35, who represents the riding of Brampton-Springdale.

"They are misrepresenting myself. they put my face on someone else's body in clothes I never wore."

The film producer Charanjit (Chico) Sihra, who owns an autobody shop in Hamilton, said Dhalla signed a distribution waiver and was paid $2,000.00

Sihra who met Dhalla at a fashion show in 1993 shortly after she placed second in the Miss India Canada pageant said he doesn't know what all the fuss is about.

"She wanted to be in a Bollywood film," Sihra said. "She had a passion for the movie, but she's a politician now and she doesn't want the DVD of the film released."

Dhalla's mother was on set every day of filming and there is no nudity or sex in the movie, he added.

Dhalla denied signing a waiver and has asked Sihra to produce it. Sihra said the form was destroyed in a fire but he has witnesses who saw Dhalla sign it.

Both sides have hired lawyers.

"If we have to go through an injunction, we'll do whatever is necessary," Dhalla said.

She claims the producer and distributor in India are "opportunists" trying to exploit her status as a politician.

Thoughts? I may not know the entire story here, but, isn't it really convenient how the waiver was "lost in a fire" ? You'd think a director, producer, or anyone for that matter would have forms or papers of importance like that tucked away in a fire, flood and damage proof some where... Or am I the only one that would do that?

Social Bookmarking

Saturday, January 10, 2009

Former Chretien chief of staff dies

Jean Pelletier, one of former prime minister Jean Chretien's closest confidants and a focal point of the Gomery commission, has died in Quebec City at the age of 73.

Jean Pelletier died Saturday morning at the Maison Michel-Sarrazin, a hospice for cancer patients in the final stages of their disease.

Before he died, the former mayor of Quebec City was visited by friends and family, along with current mayor Regis Labeaume and Chretien, his old colleague.


Pelletier was a well-known figure in the provincial capital, which UNESCO recognized as a world heritage site under his leadership.

But while he had many successes during his political career, the one-time journalist became a well-known national figure during the federal sponsorship scandal.


The former Chretien chief-of-staff was criticized by retired judge John Gomery, who conducted a probe into the scandal in which ad agencies were paid large sums by the Liberal government for little or no work.

Justice Gomery said that Jean Pelletier and Jean Chretien bore some responsibility for the scandal, but in the summer of 2008, a federal court struck down the finding. His friend Eddie Goldenberg told The Canadian Press that the decision was a "total vindication" for Pelletier and Chretien.

Jean Pelletier also went to court after former prime minister Paul Martin fired him from his job as head of Via Rail in 2004. He was let go after he called Olympic gold-medal winner Myriam Bedard a "pitiful" single mother and attention-seeker after she alleged there were ties between Via and the sponsorship scandal.

Pelletier apologized for his remarks. He also sued Ottawa for the dismissal and for damage to his reputation. In November of 2007, he was awarded more than $335,000 in moral damages.

Political analysts at one time described Pelletier as one of Canada's most powerful men.

Observers described him as an elegant and polite man, who could also be dictatorial. Friends and foes alike said he had an iron fist in a velvet glove, earning him the nicknames the "elegant executioner" and "velvet executioner."


He was an officer of the Order of Canada and the Order of Quebec. He was also a commander of France's Legion of Honour.

"Jean Pelletier was a man of great integrity who served his city, his province and his country with enormous dedication and integrity all of his life," said Goldenberg.

Pelletier is survived by his wife Helene and their two children, Jean and Marie.